Up until a few days ago--like most of America--you likely hadn't heard of the Jena Six. But thanks to a college student driven Internet campaign which led to massive demonstrations that drew high profile African American activists, the Jena Six controversy has seized the headlines--bringing racism and injustice front and center in every newspaper and on every television and computer monitor in America.

Apparently, despite arguments to the contrary from many gay advocates, activism is not only alive and well in America--as it did in the 60s and the 70s, it produces results. Tens of thousands of Americans converging on one small town in Louisiana from all over the United States accomplished in a few hours what our gay advocates have failed to accomplish over a time frame of many years.
Consider that days before a possible ENDA vote, ENDA is not on the front pages of any newspapers or among the headlines on CNN, ABC, NBC or CBS. ENDA may represent a solution to a gross injustice and outrage that is more than equal to the issues surrounding the Jena Six, but, to put it bluntly, as has been the case since the 1950s, blacks do it better, much better. You can be damned sure that if ENDA concerned basic civil rights for African Americans, there would have been a tent city within shouting distance of Capital Hill until justice was done.
As evidenced by Stonewall, we had it right in the 60s and 70s, but we were sidetracked by AIDS in the 80s, and then further distracted by an obsession with visibility in the 90s and now, well into the first decade of a new century, we've clearly lost our taste for community and activism and seem content to be lapdogs to Democrats.
The visuals and sounds of outraged masses of African-Americans shocked Congress out of its "who gives a damn about justice" coma and within hours there was a call for a special hearing. Shortly thereafter, the hero of Katrina, the President himself, issued a statement of sympathy and promised that he would throw the full attention of the FBI and whatever else it took to address this travesty of American justice.
"The events in Louisiana have saddened me," the president told reporters at the White House. "All of us in America want there to be, you know, fairness when it comes to justice."
Thanks, Mr. President, please consider that when you call the press conference to announce your support of ENDA and same-sex marriage.
I wonder if HRC has been paying attention to all of this or have they been too busy writing letters to congressional staffers and shooting off one email after another asking for our money?
Black activism has huge accomplishments under it's belt: An end to segregation and Jim Crow laws, breathtaking equal rights legislation, federal bans on discrimination in the workplace, education and housing and a viable African American Presidential candidate.
Gay advocacy? Queers stand as the only minority left in America that remains unprotected from discrimination in the workplace, in housing, health care, social services and education. And while tens of thousands of black Americans are in the streets with raised fists, supported by thousands of white supporters, tens of well-dressed and very polite gay advocates are shooting off emails and position papers.
By now even the most irresponsible queers among us have come down long enough from their meth binges to notice something about the Jena Six. Personally, I can't stop wondering what our gay advocates make of the fact that the media has been forced to notice and address critical issues to the black community thanks to authentic activism and activist leaders like Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, while much bigger issues having to do with basic civil rights already provided some 40 years ago to women and all other minorities are still denied to us.
Sure, hundreds of American corporations and a few dozen communities provide benefits and protections for queer Americans, but it goes no farther than tokenism and carries few legal guarantees until Congress adds sexual orientation to federal law.
The Associated Press reports that "while Jena Six supporters were overwhelmingly black, young whites were also present. "I think what happened here was disgusting and repulsive to the whole state," said Mallory Flippo, a white college student from Shreveport. "I think it reflected badly on our state and how it makes it seem we view black people. I don't feel that way, so I thought I should be here.' Many white residents of Jena also expressed anger at the way news organizations portrayed this town of 3,000 people. "I believe in people standing up for what's right," said resident Ricky Coleman, 46, who is white. "What bothers me is this town being labeled racist. I'm not racist."
And where do we all stand on homophobia, gay bashing and the injustices heaped on gay teens throughout communities like Jena?
Silence.
And why not? Are gay Americans out in the streets with our activist leaders demanding and commanding national attention to the horrible injustices daily visited upon us?
No. We don't do demonstrations, half naked parades, yes, demonstrations, no.
Fanon Brown, a 16-year-old American spent 27 hours traveling from his home in Philadelphia to Jena Louisiana. He told a New York Times reporter, "I am here not just for the six black boys who were arrested for beating a white classmate after a series of incidents in the town, but for the larger things the case represents about race and justice in America. I can't believe that after all these years we still have deformities in our justice system. We have to free the Jena Six but we've got to go home and take care of this racism thing.
Diana Jones traveled from Atlanta with her 17-year-old daughter April and her husband, Derrick. "Nobody should have to ask if they can sit under this tree,'' Mrs. Jones told The Times. "I'm surprised to hear that this is still happening in 2007.''
Clearly Ms. Jones hasn't been paying attention to the plight of gay students who are frequently chased from the shade of trees on college campuses across America.
Two students from the University of Louisiana at Lafayette said they felt it was their turn to march for civil rights.
"This is the first time something like this has happened for our generation,'' said Eric Depradine, 24, who is a senior. "You always heard about it from history books and relatives. This is the chance to experience it for ourselves.''
His schoolmate, Charley Caldwell Jr., 22, who is a sophomore, said he was amazed by details of the case.
"When I first heard about it, I thought it was obscene, so I felt I had to come,'' he said. We're here to free the Jena Six."
Latese Brown, 40, a social worker from Alexandria, La., about 40 miles from Jena said: "I felt I needed to be here to support these kids. It's about time we all stood together for something.''
Indeed, Ms. Brown, indeed.
Ironically--or should I say tragically--we have the organization and the infrastructure to mount tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands for a march on Washington or even a march on Sea Cliff, New York, but we do nothing. See you at the next fund-raising gala, I suppose.
Network: 





























Comments:
(26)Add a comment
Monday 24 September
By BeeDee
Well... nobody's showing up to "counter protest" this protest against clearly racist behavior. It's socially acceptable, even in small town Louisiana to be outraged over racism. At least we've made that much progress.
However, I think it's unrealistic for you to suggest that a similar action based on clearly homophobic discrimination WOULD NOT result in sniper fire on the demonstrators from a building top, fast moving car, or dense bushes. Your article reflects a real lack of understanding or appreciation of the dangers of being out AND proud in many, too many, places in this country.
I refer you to being black AND proud in the 50's and 60's in similar small towns. That progress has yet to arrive and I think it is irresponsible to suggest that Gays and Lesbians arriving on the scene en mass would result in anything by death of the same.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Patrick
BeeDee, your comments just add more support to Richard's position. The fact that it might be somewhat dangerous for any group to assemble and protest argues that this kind of action is absolutely needed. There is an injustice taking place. And it's not like there aren't already gatherings in the form of pride parades going on all over the country. Those gatherings have lost their way, and are hurting the cause rather than helping. I'm not suggesting that anyone be sacrificed for the cause, but the shooting of Martin Luther King did more for black civil rights than any other single event. Rights aren't won by people sitting back and waiting, or dancing through the streets in funny costumes. or writing long letters to congress. They will only be won when those in power are motivated to act. And sadly, the strongest motivators for politicians are greed and fear.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Todd
BeeDee, my only response will be one from a man much greater than I.
"I submit to you that if a man hasn't discovered something he will die for, he isn't fit to live."
Martin Luther King Jr., Speech in Detroit, June 23, 1963
I believe the "comfort" of the GLBT community is, in fact, our biggest hinderance. Rights are NEVER freely given by those in power. Equality must be demanded, and demanded powerfully and consistently until it is won. History has shown this to be true time and again.
Until we, as a community, decide that we are willing to make the neccessary sacrifices and take the necessary actions to demand our full rights, we will never see any improvement: not in my lifetime, or in the future.
And yes, call me a crazy militant fag if you wish, but I, for one, am willing to take a stand and face the consequences - even if that means making personal sacrifices. I just wish more people were. Then we could create change.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By BeeDee
Ahh, the smug righteousness of urbanites... Terrific, why don't you start organizing your march right now? I'd like to suggest St Louis, MO and Grand View, GA. Too far? I have several locations in VA, TX, SC, OH, PA, and OR.
What the commenters and the author don't understand is that so many places in the US function just like Egypt. They start with you (usually as the Sherrif's Deputy drags you out of view so you can die in pain unassisted) then they go after your family. It's what's called small town justice. Sound like familial genocide? That's what it is.
In the event that the protesters leave town without a deadly incident - don't worry. All the carefully concealed gays and lesbians - and their families - that live in the area will suffer the consequence of your moment of triumph for you - for a long, long time after you've left.
You wanna move forward based on great quotes but can't really travel? Check your own back yard. Hold a protest in south central L.A., or S.E. Chicago, or Long Island - - or something truly poetic, how 'bout south Philly?
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Paul
I'm 100% with you Todd and feel the same way. Do know that you're not alone.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By REBELCOMX (Formerly Ben)
I'd like to add another quote onto Todd's response:
He who gives up freedom to obtain safety deserves neither - Benjamin Franklin.
This comfort we have acheived as a community is causing a general malaise and preventing us from doing any real work towards equality. We all seem to be content for the most bart with what we've already gotten, but there is SO much more that needs to be done. Sadly, it will take something like the Jenna 6 to happen TO the gay community for us to start to take more aggressive action. Mere visibility is no longer sufficient, it was fine for a while while we tried to make the world realize we ARE a community, unlike the black or latinos who are kinda obvious just because of the color of their skin. Our community, however includes people of all races, creeds, and nations. Visibility IS necessary...but no longer does the job. We have to break out of this comfortable complacency and get on the ball. No one has ever gained freedom simply by asking for it. No group has ever NOT lost a few lives upon the path to equality. If we as a community are too afraid to risk everything...then we can gain nothing.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Don Brown
Its a shame we are trying to get motivated by the manipulation for the fact in Jena LA. These kids should go to jail and the boy who was supposed to be sentenced on the day of the protests is a thug and most assuredly his gang of thugs would have beaten one of us to death. We shouldnt want to free them but demand the others who also were brutalizing people should also be facing justice. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jena_Six
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Todd
BeeDee,
As a point of clarity, I live in Southwest Virginia and have spent my entire life here. I am out and proud to be gay even though it is not "safe" to do so. I know LGBT oppression well. I have been assaulted, cursed, ridiculed, and gay bashed on multiple occasions. I have had the word FAG spray painted on my house. My parents were thrown out of their church because of the "unrepentant" way I "chose" to live my life, even though they don't support my "behavior." My car has been vandalized, my house has been broken into and I have to look over my shoulder when I walk down the street.
In spite of that, I have written letters to the editor of our newspaper and attempted to educate (when possible) the people I meet at work and in social settings. I attend rallies, write to my state congresspeople and senators, and display my pride sticker on my car.
My experiences, and the things you mention, are the exact reason that we must fight for equal protection under the law. These examples are the exact reason it is so important to take a stand against discrimination in employment and housing; they are the exact reason that sexual orientation and gender identity must be protected under hate crimes laws.
When I say that I am willing to sacrifice, or even die, for LGBT equality, it is not just lip service. It is a reality that I face every day. That makes it all the more important to me to see this battle won in my lifetime.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Richard
I just want to add to this discussion that if I knew that someone might shoot me for marching for gay rights in any part of this nation, I would wear the brightest shirt in my closet (which happens to be orange) and I would do so proudly with my head held high. I can't imagine a better way to die.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By Michael Cantillo
I agree with Richard. I would die in battle anyday, even though the brightest shirt in my closet is navy blue...however, we are a lazy people, too interested in the way we look rather than the way people perceive us, which are two different things. We can never have the force that such a large number of black citizens have,because our people are in the closet, and the straights outnumber us...but we can still try and that's what counts. We are supposed to be "proud" to be americans and "proud" to be lgbt, but it's become "arrogant" american and "arrogant" lgbt, the declining moral values of homosexuals concerns me because we're beginning to make Anita Bryant sound like a prophet. if we're ever going to achieve equal rights we have to demand an increase in awareness and delineate the stereotypes that people have about us through the portrayal of the entire lgbt community not just the femme fatales(and by that i mean gurrrls....) and butchy women....i hope i've given you something to think about...it's become a joke to speak about civil rights especially among the gay community. :(
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Lexi
I completely agree with this entire post. I think that it is just most gays are just content with being "tolerated". However, who knows for sure what they reason behind us nothing doing anything is.
Now as for "The Jena Six" this is being entirely blown out of proportion. Two wrongs do NOT make a right. The whites should not have hung the nooses, yes. However, that does not GIVE six boys the right to nearly beat someone to death. Pretty much everyone in this entire situation, is wrong.
and the jena six should NOT be freed, because nothing makes what they did okay.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Spencer
Lexi is right about the Jena Six. What they did was completely wrong, as was what the white boys did.
Most gays are NOT tolerated where I live, and people have paintballed the side of my house, vandelized my car, written obscene words everywhere on my property, and even went as far as to hang two flags in my yard. One was saying that I supported Hitler (which I most certinly do NOT) and the other said 'Welcome to the devil's home!'
It needs to stop. If you don't like it, news flash- I'm not here to please you.
Reply
Monday 24 September
By Denny
Excellent post, Mr. Rothstein.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By MIlo
I am seventeen, and I live in Alexandria, Louisiana, less than an hour's drive from Jena. I am openly gay, and I go to a boarding school where gays aren't just tolerated, we are welcomed.
The uproar caused by the Jena Six is on a scale that has rocked my town and all those around it in ways they have never seen before. I would love to see such demonstrations for LGBT causes, and I would support them and admire those who start them, but I don't think that is going to happen.
The difference between African American demonstrators and us is that we don't have as much to gain from our struggles. We live in relative comfort, blogging and posting with the fear of gay bashing over our heads, but for me at least, that has never been a reality.
For many African Americans, this is far from the truth.
Hundreds of thousands of African Americans all across the nation live in poverty. They live in the worst neighborhoods, in some of the worst conditions in our nation.
How many open gays live in that type of squalor?
It is extremely possible that I am just under-informed, but if we are tolerated, we have already gained a great victory. Our problem is that we content ourselves with this victory and ask for nothing more.
African Americans have won victories above and beyond our own, but many still live in much more fear than many of us will ever experience. That is their reality, and it is something that many of them can never escape.
There's a street in Alexandria, less than a mile from Bolton High School, the best high school in the parish. I think it's Marye Street, but I'm not certain. Less then five years ago, there were shootings on that street every single day. Living on that street is living in fear, the type of total fear that motivates action.
Living knowing that others in your boat have been killed is nowhere near as good a motivator.
The Jena Six is a chance for African Americans everywhere to draw attention to their plight and give them a chance to free themselves of that fear and that stereotype. We just don't have the motivation.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By nick
I cant believe that this stuff is happening today, its a disgrace that in this country people will critizise and threaten people because of the color of there skin.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By xeraph
I believe that gay culture was nearly ripe for being co-opted by capitalism when significant gains were being made in the 60s and 70s. When gays gained more economic power, it was a certain sector of gays that did so (primarily white and falling within a certain range of gender deviancy), leaving the rest behind, and they remain behind today. But because gayness is not a family trait, it does not cluster in one socioeconomic bracket; the assimilation of gays into all classes of society is made possible by capitalism in some ways, by passability as straight in others, and by real tolerance forged by civil rights battles.
I still think that being out is one of the best and often the most vulnerable form of activism. Refusing to become complacent and assimilated is even better. With no option to hide, it makes sense that Black people have always fought for options outside of assimilation and invisibility, choosing instead pride, cultural unity, and opposition to institutional oppression that affects many groups. I get this "I just wanna be loved," vibe from many gay 'activists' and media sources. I don't want society at large to love me, at least not unless it changes radically in many, many ways. I'd rather it was a bit afraid of me. I'm rather it wasn't sure what I have up my sleeve. But then again, I'm trans, so I don't have the option to hide. I know I'm not going to be very loved, that I'm very unlikely to have access to certain types of power. So of course I'm willing to be disobedient.
What I wish most powerfully and most often, though, is that the gender deviants and very obviously queer people did not have to be quite so alone in their fight. I wish more bisexuals would come out, and stay out, and talk about it. I wish more people who can pass as straight but aren't would choose to be political about it. It helps build the bridges that support those who fight because they have no choice. I wish more people publically and socially identified as allies. For you, it is just a little bit more vulnerability, but if you won't take it on, you make people like me carry all the difference. I'm tired of being the very queer person among the closeted and semicloseted, folks who snatch privilege whenever they can. Let's say NO to all privileges and start demanding rights & real pride in sexual and gender diversity.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By TheFabulousThomasJ.
Where have you been?
Larry Kramer has been yelling long and loud for years, but does anyone listen?
No.
We're more interested in our Circuit Parties and the latest episode of Project Runway.
We deem Larry Kramer a nutjob, when, in fact, he had it right all the time.
Perhaps with what's going on in the South these days, we might review the situation?
And, BTW, these days, I bite the fat rumps of Democrats, not sit in their laps.
Tom
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By jake
Beedee, I find myself forced to respond to your concern that we're placing ourselves in danger by protesting.
Um Yeah!
That being the point.
In the '80's I belonged to ACT/UP Kansas City. we mounted a protest one day at a Wal-Mart in Blue Springs, Missouri.
More than one bib-overall-wearing farmer with a gun in the window of his pickup truck drove by yelling obscenities.
Now that was a harrowing experience.
And I'd do it again today given the chance.
To borrow a well put phrase;
"Give me liberty or give me death."
It's no less true now than it was then.
Sometimes we have to give everything for what we beileve in. Just ask any of the soldiers George Bush has sent to their deaths.
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By Ken Stofft
THERE'S A NEW CLOSET FOR GAYS TODAY! It's called marriage, the white picket fence around a white house with a dog, cat, and a drop-dead handsome partner! Well, maybe the condo instead of the house! We've been coopted into yet another closet and we've been duped to believe it's what we want. Duped by our own!
And, we think this is going to work?! Hell no. Why would it work since it doesn't work for the millions of straight folks (and the married-to-female gay men). Sexism and heterosexism doesn't work for them, why do gay men and women think it's going to work for them?!
And, yes, HRC just keeps putting on the fund-raisers to get us what the heteros have (don't have). Legal rights is imperative, but why model it after a system that doesn't work?
And, that's not all! The gay news media doesn't pay attention to what's happening under it's own noses! Advertizing chemicals to make us into the best desirable men going! Telling us the only way to be a "man" is to wear the right clothes, watch the right tv programs, drink the right drinks, blah, blah, blah...mouthing it like sheep and goats.
We're doing ourselves in by not facing up to the reality around us: Conform at all cost! Don't we queers have a better mission in life?
Yes, I hope this Jena 6 injustice awakens us to do something NOW!
Reply
Tuesday 25 September
By Ken Stofft
GAYS IN A NEW CLOSET OF THEIR OWN MAKING! Yep, we've been coopted by the sexist/heterosexist culture and we don't even see it! Give us our designer clothes, our gorgeous body, our sarcasm, our in your face attitude, our drop-dead partner, our careers...and the hell with the rest! Like lemmings we have been following the pied piper to the edge of "conformity"! OUCH!
I thought we queers had a mission in life! The Jena 6 injustice is just scratching the surface of bigotry in this country....and among white queers! The Jena 6 rallies are an indication that people can gather for a just cause and that queers need to wake up and get organized themselves. The HRC doesn't get it! Most of the gay media doesn't get it! The gay entertainment industry doesn't get it!
If a gay man or woman was given the choice of taking a pill to make them hetero, would he/she take it?! My fear is that some would! OMG!
Who's the enemy? It's US.
Reply